The summary should be in your own words, not the author's. A difficult part of evaluation of a published text and a professional author is how to do this as a student. In this chapter, the author argues that the role of women was overlooked in previous scholarship because most of them were widows who made their financial bequests to libraries in the names of their husbands. Purpose The purpose of the critical book review for history is to share information about an historical topic - it is not a book report that summarizes the content. Are you able to detect any underlying philosophy of history held by the author e.
Provide alternate points of view. Is the argument well supported, with good documentation or does it have contradictions? Identify the main ideas of the work in order to analyze its structure. Tenzer's The Forgotten Cause of the Civil War suggests that one of the major contributions to tension between North and South - and hence one of the causes of the civil war - was white slavery, or the perception of slavery by Northerners as a personal threat. The answers should be part of a carefully constructed essay, complete with topic sentences and transitions. Book review is written in order to understand whether students are able to evaluate the content of a book critically.
Do they conform to or depart from the conventions of its genre? In fact, your paper will be more interesting if you state your main argument s as quickly as possible. Students have to analyze a book based on the manner of writing, style, and content. The introduction is important in that it draws in the reader's attention and interest, and makes clear what you're going to be discussing in your paper. Use the literature to support your views. Try to figure out what the filmmaker was trying to say with the film.
This is the equivalent to a thesis statement. They include the ways that the main character attempts to resolve the conflict. Education, class, ethnicity, nationality, gender, and political or religious affiliations may affect the authors expertise, bias, or interpretation. No matter which areas you choose to write about, each major thought should be given its own paragraph. Relation of point to first book B. The Forgotten Cause of the Civil War A New Look at the Slavery Issue Lawrence R. You can also include key details about the author, including how the book fits into his overall body of work, its success in reaching its target audience and how the title of the book gives clues about its theme or subject.
Both types are described further down. One reason to summarise the text is that the reader may not have read the text. Is it the same or are the books intended for difference sets of readers? As a reviewer, you should combine an accurate, analytical reading with a strong, personal touch. Take Character Notes Take notes on the characters within the story. Include information on the details the author uses, and provide missing information if applicable.
What happened, why is it interesting, why or how did it happen? Methods of Organization Organization is critical to writing an essay that compares and contrasts multiple works because you will most likely be discussing a variety of evidence and you must be certain that the logic and narrative flow of your paper can be understood by the reader. The basic purpose of a book review is to convey and evaluate the following: a. A selection is a shorter piece of reading, often an essay or chapter out of a longer written work. Write a concluding paragraph or several sentences that sum up your critical analysis of the book. The objectives in book reviews between the disciplines are different animals. Finally, write a concluding paragraph that restates your opinion of the work and offers any suggestions for improvement. Is it detailed or very general? Tenzer's The Forgotten Cause of the Civil War suggests that one of the major contributions to tension between North and South - and hence one of the causes of the civil war - was white slavery, or the perception of slavery by Northerners as a personal threat.
If you are interested in contributing a book review, you may also like to look at in your discipline. To determine what it is, consider what the main character spends most of the time doing or thinking about. If this is the case, then the thesis could, for example, center around the diversity of issues scholars have chosen to examine or the fractured nature of scholarship on the topic. Does this work build on prior research or does it seem to represent a new area of research? As part of the introduction, briefly state your overall evaluation of the work. Regardless of length, it must be succinct, accurate, unbiased, and clear.
More attention should be paid to opinions and reflections of students. Be sure to note important omissions of sources that you believe should have been utilized. The first heading can be the introduction while the second heading can be the literary objective. Book reviews also provide the historian with a thumbnail sketch of the contents - that may be very useful in research work. Disclaimer: I received a review copy of The Forgotten Cause of the Civil War from the Scholars' Publishing House, but I have no stake, financial or otherwise, in its success.
Here you should definitely use examples to support your evaluation. Primary evidence is contemporary to the problem being studied. Do the entries contribute to the overall work? Include broad details or concepts, but be selective and focus on the most significant ones. Arguments are intended to extend our knowledge, and also can be described as having three parts: a premise, supporting evidence, and a conclusion. You need to remember to locate and analyse the author's argument when you are writing your critical review. Use examples to amplify your responses.
The conflict is sometimes internal. In my first attempt to do a critical book review I examined a number of critical book reviews in history in search of the common elements. Examine the Front Matter and Back Matter Front matter refers to anything before the first chapter of the book. Does the author cover it completely? Hawthorne does this with long, descriptive sentences that are strung together with commas and semi-colons, and he also uses antiquated word choices and descriptors that are rooted in the Romantic period and in Puritan terms inspired by the Bible. The Introduction Book reviews are short and concise, they may vary from half a page to several pages depending on the assignment. The body is important in that it's where most of the real discussion takes place.